IF I SEEK US

Imminent FulfillmentImmortality,  Safety, Empowerment, Equality, KnowledgeUnity, Society

"There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to
  one who is striking at the root."
- Henry David Thoreau
Site Sections, Subject List, Reading Sequence, and Article Synopses

Christendom Analyzed

Christendom Issues
Christendom Analyzed
Christianity & Hellenism
God is Dead Movement
John the Baptist Syndrome
Basic Questions
What Went Wrong?
Weeping for Lazarus
Religion as a Product
Greying of the Prophets

Site Section Links

Introduction Material
Introduction Articles
Word Definitions
Human Condition

Christianity Material
Christendom Analyzed
Christendom Challenged
Christendom Condemned
Bible/Canon Issues

Jesus Material
Jesus' Teachings
Aspects of Jesus
5 Gospels of Canon

Philosophy Material
Paradigm Material
Philosophical Issues
Psychological Issues
Theological Issues

Cosmology, Creation,
Geophysical Material
Creation Issues
Geophysical Material
Cosmology Material

Reconstruction &
Mythology Material
Modern Mythology Material
Misc Ancient Myth Material
Saturn-Jupiter Material
Venus-Mars Material
Language-Development
Symbol Development
1994 Velikovsky Symposium
Psycho-Catastrophe Articles
Chronology Revision

Miscellaneous Material
Misc Biology Lins
Misc Issues/Conclusions
Poetry & Fun Material
PDF Download Files
Lecture & Video Links
Spiritual Products online store

 

Authentic religion encourages questions and reflection at all levels.
Kimball, Charles, When Religion Becomes Evil, Los
Angeles, HarperCollins Publishers, Inc. 2002

Basic Questions for Theology
10/03/2018

How do weavoid BUFFALO CHIPS?

(Breaking Under Final Frustration About Losing Our Carelessly Hatched Institutional Philosophical Systems)?

What is the Deal for us?

1.  What is the deal that Jesus is offering to us? Is it really good for us, or does it just seem good to us, or is it just supposed to seem good to us? And is it really believable?
2.  Is it meaningfully good, that is, is it what we really want and need? Do we really know what we want and need? If the deal is different than what we really want, CAN we CHANGE what we want? SHOULD we change what we really want? If so, HOW do we change what we really want? What if we don't want to change what we want? Did we have anything to DO with what we naturally want and need?
3.  Is the deal even palatable to anyone?  A few?  Quite a few?  Most?  Everyone? If not, WHY not?
4. If God doesn't impose it on us, what does it cost us or how do we earn it? If so, is the price reasonable? Is it free, reasonable, or does it cost us everything?
5. Is it easy to qualify, is it difficult to qualify, is it excruciating, or is it just simple?

Prayer

1.  What are we authorized by Jesus to pray or ask for?
2.  Are there any conditions? If so, do the conditions apply equally to each thing authorized? Is there a sequence so that the granting of one thing leads to greater authorizations?
3.  Are the promises made to individuals or to a plural you?  Are some made to individuals and some to a corporate body? If so, what are the conditions that apply? Are they different for individuals and groups? If some are made to a corporate body, how many individuals are necessary to qualify? Is the number different for different intentions?

Disciples

1.  Was there a point in time recorded or implied in the Gospels when the disciples were in unity, or a time when they believed everything that Jesus said and acted accordingly? Or understood everything he said, or followed the advice of Jesus?
2.  Did all of the disciples understand the full truth that Jesus presented? Did any? If some, who did and who didn't? Is there any evidence or basis for discriminating between believing and non-believing disciples?
3.  The disciples ultimately didn't stay together. Was this because they were "called" to go in different directions and countries? Or was it because ultimately there was nothing much going on and holding them together, or was it that they ultimately couldn't get along comfortably?
4.  What is the essence of the difference between Christianity and Gnosticism? Which is more true or spiritual or reasonable? Which is more fallacious or dangerous? And why?
5.  Which of the disciples became the foundation for Christendom? Which of the disciples became the foundation for Gnosticism, the other great movement spawned by the Jesus incident?
6.  If Christianity and Gnosticism didn't go off the track with the disciples, exactly when and where did they go off the track?

New Testament

1.  Did Jesus authorize the writing of the New Testament? If so, where and when in what HE said did HE authorize it? If not, why has so much attention been paid to it? Has God put his stamp of approval on the New Testament? If so, what is that stamp of approval? What or where is the foundation for thinking that God authorized any of the early church apostles to speak for him rather than to elucidate the message of Jesus germane information?
2.  Has the NT stood the test of time? If so, by what criteria? If so, what is the evidence or argument for this? Has anyone seriously tried to live in accordance with the NT instructions? If so, were they successful? Is it possible? Has anyone come up with the final, correct, true interpretation of the book Revelation? If not, would you like to try?

Gospels

1.  Did Jesus authorize the writing of the Gospels? If so, where and when did he do it? Has God put his stamp of approval on them? If so, what is that stamp of approval?
Why are the Gospels riddled with discrepancies? Have the Gospels stood the test of time? If so, what is the evidence? Has anyone seriously tried to live according the Gospels? If so, were they successful? Is it possible?
3.  Is there any other material or Gospel writing outside of the NT that is of value? If so, How can it be identified and validated?
4.  Are the Gospels all of equal validity or reliability? From what standpoint?  Technical or spiritual? If not, which one(s) take precedence? If not, how can we decide?
5.  Does the Gospel of John being an eyewitness while the others are compilations of second or third hand accounts have any significance? If not, why not?
6.  Why can't the Gospel of Thomas, an eyewitness account, be considered just as, or more authoritative, than the other Gospels?

Issues of Consistency

1.  Can we treat the bible as an organic whole, that is, does it have total internal consistency? If so, what does this consistency look like? Isn't this idea an unwise fabrication?
2.  If not with total internal Biblical consistency, does the New Testament have total internal consistency? If so, what does this consistency look like?
3.  If not with total internal NT consistency, do the Gospels have total internal consistency? If so, what does this consistency look like? If not, where do we look for consistency?
4.  If not with total internal consistency, does the book of John have total internal consistency? If so, what does this consistency look like?

Issues of Accuracy

1.  Are there any parables, stories, ideas, issues, advice, instructions, or facts within the four Gospels that are in serious or significant conflict? We know there are significant conflicts.
2.  How do we deal with these inconsistencies, controversies, and conflicts? If we deal with them, how do we resolve these inconsistencies and conflicts?

Revelation/Inspiration

1.  Are revelation and inspiration equivalent? If so, what do they mean?
2.  If they are not equivalent, what is revelation? What is inspiration? What is the difference? Is either one reliable in and of itself? If not, are they reliable only when taken together?

Intellectual versus Spiritual

1.  Given that they are different from intelligent, do the words intellectual and spiritual mean the same thing? If not, do they mean largely the same thing? If not, are they related to any significant degree? Is one a subset of or dependent on the other?
2.  What does spiritual mean? What does intellectual mean? What is the difference?
3.  What about intellectual responsibility? Is it foundational, or is there just a place or role for it?

Categories of Communication

1.  Do the words or messages of Jesus fall into different categories? If so, does Jesus speak to issues of paradigm? Does he speak about truths that apply to the paradigm? Does he speak truths that can only be understood rightly in the proper paradigm?
2.  Does Jesus ever just offer good advice for the time or temporary context? If so, is all the advice recorded in the Gospels applicable to our time? IS somw? Is any? Is it always applicable to our situation?
3.  Are there levels of importance about various things Jesus said? Did he say anything that is trivial, incidental or not important? Was some of Jesus' advice applicable only to the disciples? Was some of Jesus advice applicable only to the people of that time? How do we sort this all out?

Hidden Truths

1.  Since Jesus thanked the father for hiding truths from certain men, why did God hide these truths? And from whom? Why did Jesus say that he spoke in parables so that the masses would hear and NOT understand? Why speak to them at all if he knew they wouldn't understand? Was he building a case against them, or surreptitiously plowing their spiritual ground?
2.  Was there a spiritual elite? If so, were the disciples the spiritual elite of the time? If so, was there a spiritual elite within the disciples? If so, who were these disciples? How can we tell who they were? Should there be a spiritual elite? If so, is there a purpose to a spiritual elite? Did ANYBODY understand all of what Jesus said and did during his sojourn on earth? Or later?

Righteousness

1.  Does righteousness mean right behavior? If it does, right by what standard? If it doesn't mean this, does it have any real or significant versus imaginary meaning at all?
2.  Does righteousness mean reasonable behavior? If not, what is the difference between right behavior and reasonable behavior?

Behavior

1.  Is behavior any concern at all to the follower of Jesus? If so, what does proper behavior for a follower look like?
2.  Can we get specific about right behavior or can we only generalize? If specific, is there any specific behavior that is totally proscribed by Jesus? Is all or any of our behavior demanded?  Commanded? Who does our behavior affect?  Us?  Others?  God?  All of the above?

Agenda of Creator

1.  Does the creator have a sacred agenda to impose on us?
2.  If so, is this agenda chronological? If so, are we locked into it regardless of what we do or not do? If not, what can we do about it, or how can we affect it?
3.  If the agenda is not one of time, is it one of phenomena? If so, are we locked into it, that is, is there anything we can do to affect it? If so, what can we do about it?

Behavior of Christendom

1.  Why is there so much dissension and hypocrisy in Christian religions when Jesus said the devil was defeated?
2.  Why did Christianity stamp out so-called Gnostic sects with the sword when the virtue, piety and behavior of some of these generally exceeded that of Christians?

Words of Jesus

1.  Did Jesus ever give good advice that applied specifically to that time? Did Jesus ever give good advice that applied specifically to that culture? Did Jesus ever give good advice that applied specifically to explicit situations? Did he say some things to the disciples that do not apply to us? Did he say some things to some of the disciples that did not apply to the other disciples? Do some things he said apply to different believers depending on their level of belief?
2. Did Jesus emphasize certain things that he said? If so, how has that come down to us?

Salvation

1.  Does the salvation offered by Jesus mean being saved from ultimately being lost or punished or destroyed?
2.  Does the salvation offered by Jesus mean being saved from being temporarily lost or punished or destroyed? Does it mean being healed and restored spiritually versus tangibly and physically? Does it mean both? If so, which comes first? Do they happen simultaneously?
3. Is the salvation offered by Jesus complete and actally IMMINENT?

Unity

1.  What does it mean to come into unity? How do we become unified? Are there specific steps? Are they unpleasant or burdensome? Are they difficult? If difficult, what is the key to making them easy? If easy, why don't we do it? If we understood the essence, scope, imminence and immanence of the payoff, would that make it easy? Would being truly "rooted in self" help make it easy?
2.  Is anyone out there in perfect unity? Does anyone truly want to come into unity? Does anyone truly not want to come into unity? Does anyone believe it is possible to come into perfect unity?

Free Moral Agency

1.  Did God create man to be a free moral agent? If not, are we any more than sophisticated, programmable robots? If so, does this mean that man is free to exercise his own judgment and do what he thinks is good without fear of consequences? If it doesn't mean this, what does it mean?
2.  Do we create, enlarge or foster free moral agency for our family and friends? Are they actually at liberty to exercise their own judgment and do what they think is good without risking the loss of the relationship?

Testing of Believers

1.  Having made Man of course without Man's choice or permission, why would God subject Man to arbitrary prohibitions which, if ignored, would cost Man his life at the hand of God? Why would God need to test Man in any way whatsoever?
2.  Do we subject members of our family and friends to testing? Is this a loving or moral thing to do? Do we feel loved if members of our family or friends subject us to testing? Why should we test them, and if they fail, lose our love, support, and association?
3.  How can a God gracious enough to give His own son to mankind have ever been so ungracious as to forbid Man the fruit from a mere tree? Has God become more "Christlike" down through the ages? Why should life EVER have been anything but a pure gift of grace?

Obedience/Submission/Surrender

1.  Why should God need to be obeyed? Why should the one who has the power to create the heavens need anyone to do anything for him? Does God need to rule or govern through law backed up by punishment and ultimately death?
2.  Does Man need fiat law above and beyond natural law? Does Man need to obey fiat Law? Did fiat law really come from God or just come from Moses or myth fabrication? Why should an intelligent creature made in the likeness of God need to obey anything other than his own native feelings? Why should he be asked to despise, ignore or violate his authentic desires in order to comply with rules or requirements he had no part in forming?

Relationship with God

1.  Why does Christianity teach that God demands to be "numero uno" in our lives? Isn't this the essence of being insecure and self-centered? And if so, how does this square with "By this shall all men know that you are my followers, that you love one another as I have loved you?"
2. Why would God demand our worship and love? Demanding these of other humans, is the one most certain thing to kill them in others. Cannot a relationship thrive through inspiration and love? Cannot a society function through inspiration and good will?

20 Questions that need the right answers!

1.      What is soteria (swthria), usually translated "Salvation?"

  1. Having your name written in the book of life with the assurance that you will "go to heaven" at death or the end of the world.
  2. Actually being safe from harm and danger because of the protection of God.
  3. Being physically and psychologically healthy, so as to enjoy the time, family and friends one has in life and so to not alienate people or harm them.
  4. Actually being physically and psychologically safe because of being immortal and empowered along with other members of the human race.
  5. Other:

2.      The word "sin" as a verb is an ancient Mars rooted term meaning to miss the mark (Mars was the "eye of the bull") when you are shooting an arrow or throwing a spear, etc., as a noun referring to the distance of the hit from the bulls eye or center.  Sin is also used to refer to some underlying condition which causes a person to miss the mark when he is sincerely trying to hit it.  When Jesus used this term did he mean missing the mark primarily in terms of?:

  1. Obeying God's law.
  2. Behaving perfectly.
  3. Our personal relationship to God.
  4. Our concepts and understanding of God and ourselves.
  5. Other:

3.      What does logos (logos), traditionally translated "Word" mean?

  1. The Word of God, the message of the Bible.
  2. The New Testament.
  3. The red letter words, the words of Jesus.
  4. A rational truth which can be considered, questioned, discussed and understood; in contrast to mythos, which can only be accepted or rejected because it is beyond our understanding.
  5. Other:

4.      What is the Ecclesia (ekklhsia), traditionally translated "church" to which Jesus referred?

  1. A special building dedicated to God.
  2. An organization dedicated to furthering the work of God.
  3. A group of people committed to loving and supporting one another in the name of God.
  4. A group of people in an unacceptable and urgent state of affairs, who come together to discuss important issues and make the right choices for belief and decisions for action..
  5. Other:

5.      What is worship?

  1. Partaking in a ceremony that is focused on God.
  2. Coming to "church" once a week.
  3. Singing, praying and talking about God.
  4. Giving credit for the origin, and more especially for the sustenance and enhancement of one's own life, and appreciating the incredible loving and sharing character of the creator.
  5. Other:

6.      What is the Holy Pneuma, traditionally translated Holy Spirit?

  1. An incorporeal entity, like a ghost, the third person of the godhead.
  2. The mystical, omnipresence of God.
  3. The inanimate attitude and mentality of the members of the godhead.
  4. The attitude of loving the truth and believing that the truth is important, the indomitable attitude of refusing to believe anything but the best about God and refusing defeat.
  5. The "I am a God" attitude.
  6. Other

7.      What is the role of the Holy Pneuma

  1. To indwell and thereby control the True Believers.
  2. To act as the conscience of the True Believer.
  3. To influence us to think and behave righteously and morally.
  4. To provide us with mystical experiences such as feeling the presence of God, and to convey messages through visions, voices and dreams.
  5. To teach us all pertinent things, lead us into all the truth and a complete understanding of God, his purpose, values and plan.
  6. Other:

8.      Usually translated, "soul" in the New Testament, but sometimes "life", what does the word psyche (yuch) mean, and where does it come from?

  1. The true inner self that comes from God, and departs the body when a person dies.
  2. The immortal "God within" that is all wise, all good and remains untarnished despite even the most sordid of lives.
  3. The personality—foibles, warts and all—that is the product of genetics and environment.
  4. The entire psychology of a person, including the persona and the conscious mind, and the individual's underlying metaphysics or paradigm. It manifests itself in the personality, attitude, feelings and character of the individual; it is molded, and nurtured or abused by other people, one's own mental activity and one's own experiences.
  5. The pattern and content of experience of a person's life.
  6. Other:

9.      What does the word  "religion" mean?

  1. A belief system that has enough adherents to be taken seriously.
  2. A belief system that has God as it's focus.
  3. A belief system that deals with spiritual matters versus secular matters.
  4. A philosophy binding people together again through logic and understanding.
  5. Other:

10.  What is the Devil Diaβoloς) meaning "slanderer" or "divider"?

  1. A Supreme being of evil, possibly immortal.
  2. An angel of the highest rank who has fallen and become hardened in his opposition to God.
  3. The separated and fallen collective consciousness—comparable to the godhead—to which we belong.
  4. The original lie spawning the prevalent mentality that God is superior and beyond human, and less magnanimous than he really is.
  5. Other:

11.  What is the Bible?

  1. The infallible Word of God.
  2. A newspaper account of history and the plan of salvation, whereby the good news must be sorted out from the bad.
  3. A collection of human writings that have been influenced by God just enough to give us a chance to know the truth.
  4. The OT is a combination of the "constructed" history and  mythology of the Hebrew people, and the NT is, with the exception of the valid information about Jesus, the history and  mythology of apostolic—especially Paulinist—Christendom.
  5. Other:

12.  What is being righteous?

  1. Being in conformity to the "law of God".  
  2. Being untainted by the ways of the world.
  3. Being warm and loving toward other people.
  4. Understanding the purpose of life and being reasonable in the context of the sustenance and enhancement of life.
  5. Other:

13.  What is the structural nature of God?

  1. God is one person, but who can simultaneously perform three different roles
  2. God is one person, but who can put on different faces or persona
  3. God is a corporate being that is composed of three distinct persons in unity
  4. Who can know?
  5. God is a corporate being or agency composed of an unknown number of distinct unfallen humans that are in complete and totally effective unity
  6. Other:

14.  What is legalism?

  1. Believing that obeying God's law is the way to righteousness.
  2. Believing that it is important to obey the "law of God" as best we can, with the difference made up for us.
  3. An emphasis upon conformity to the "law of God".
  4. Any system of thinking where God is conceived to be a moral fiat law giver, and any or all of its attendant aspects of our having to have a focus on this law.
  5. Other:

15.  What is the Parousia, usually referred to as the "second coming"?

  1. A future event at the end of the world as we know it, where Jesus will come in the clouds with legions of angels and take the righteous to reign with him.
  2. A personal event, where the individual is "raptured" as soon as they are "ready".
  3. An internal event, which takes place when the individual becomes enlightened enough to achieve "Christ Consciousness".
  4. A past event, where Jesus came into public prominence through the his message, life behavior, demonstration on the cross and the resurrection, all of which served to reveal the character of God.
  5. The word literally means the display of presence.
  6. Other:

16.  What is the nature of "Truth"?

  1. Truth is relative – you have yours and I have mine.
  2. The Truth can never be fully known, but we will spend eternity learning about it.
  3. Truth is self-created, it is manifested from one's beliefs.
  4. Truth is the adequately complete, big-picture understanding of ourselves, God, and reality.
  5. Other:

17.  What is hell?

  1. A place,realm or situation of eternal fiery torture for the wicked.
  2. The temporary "Lake of Fire" that consumes the wicked at the end of this world.
  3. The state of being lost and dead forever.
  4. The vicissitudes of life in this world.
  5. There is no such place or realm; the words "hades" and "gehenna" refer to places other than the Christian "Hell"..
  6. Other:

18.  What is believing?

  1. Hanging onto what you've been taught as hard as you can, for as long as you can, despite the winds of change and challenging evidence to the contrary.
  2. Holding to a given set of concepts composed of knowledge and opinions, though not necessarily one's own.
  3. Having faith that Jesus "did it all."
  4. Taking responsibility for actively choosing what you hold to be true to the point of understanding, and ultimately putting the focus of your life on the line for it.
  5. Other:

19.  In John 17, Jesus called for unity of the believers in the most emphatic and eloquent way.  What is the unity that he calls for?

  1. Belonging to a congregation where everyone holds the same doctrines.
  2. Belonging to a PLU (People Like Us) congregation and getting along reasonably well.
  3. Belonging to a congregation of People Not Like Us and getting along reasonably well.
  4. Unity of purpose, values, concepts and understanding of God and ourselves.
  5. Other:

20.  Jesus is often quoted as saying  "if two or three of you agree on anything, ask whatever you will and it will be given you".  If Jesus was for real, why does this seldom if ever happen?

  1. Jesus spoke in parables and symbolic terms; we can't take sayings like this literally.
  2. This promise is only in effect when other stringent qualifications are met, such as believing intensely enough or having enough faith.
  3. It only happens when we correctly ascertain and "pray the will of God".
  4. The text, more accurately translated, says "when two or three of you agree on everything that matters…"; it will only happen after two or three, (or more) have come into real unity of purpose, values, and concepts.
  5. Other:

Four additional important Questions for Christians

We live in a messed up mad-house world where we are fragmented into a hundred thousand religions which are primarily based on fear and are mutually exclusive as to truth.  Not one religion, ideology, denomination, sect, organization, dogma, doctrine or individual is in a majority.  All of these religions, etc., cannot be right, but they CAN all be wrong.  Seven billion homo sapiens live in a physically hostile environment where we are subject to danger, damage, disease and dying, where we at best live a short life subject to many so-called vicissitudes and where we inexorably age and die.  As Thomas Hobbs put it, “The life of man....solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short".

Question 1.     How did we get into this physically and spiritually messed up situation?

Commentary: About 400,000 homo sapiens are born every day, and about 350,000 die every day. Of the latter, probably around 7 or 8 from lightning strikes, hundreds burn to death or drown, thousands die of starvation, hundreds are killed in accidents, hundreds killed by poisonous creature bites or stings, hundreds tortured and killed in warfare, thousands by suicide, tens of thousands by wasting away from debilitating disease, etc. Get the picture? There seems to be no pattern of evidence that God is currently involved in our world in any significant tangible way.
     One thing should be clear: When it all started to go bad, you and I were not even born yet and had nothing to do with it.

Question 2.    If there is a God, why is God not involved, or at least involved in a more visible, tangible and therefore more meaningful way?

Commentary: For any of this to make sense to a reasonable man, there should be a VERY powerful reason for the minimally involved God. It should also be clear that God is waiting for US to do something, that we should not be waiting for God.

Question 3.     What can we do to change or get out of this situation?

Commentary: Do we just have to wait, OR, has the great teacher given us instructions that have NEVER been understood or followed? 

Question 4.   Are millions of Christians making a huge mistake in praying to God, begging God, trying to influence or manipulate God into answering their petty, mundane, self-centered petitions, instead of endeavoring to answer God's prayer concerning unity in John 17?

Commentary: The "Lord's Prayer" is the example of what our prayers should look like, and it has NONE of the above list of unbidden requests. When the disciples lost their empowerment because of a failure to understand resulting in divisive competition and bickering, why is it so hard for Christians to see that the backing of God and success are tied to our understanding of the truth and unity in that truth?
 

Home  Site Sections  Complete Article Map   Contact  Store  Contributions