IF I SEEK US

Imminent FulfillmentImmortality,  Safety, Empowerment, Equality, KnowledgeUnity, Society

"There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to
  one who is striking at the root."
- Henry David Thoreau
Site Sections, Subject List, Reading Sequence, and Article Synopses

Miscellaneous Articles

Can We Agree on these?
Critical Issues
Unity Agreement Outline
Valid vs feaux intellectuals
Some Atheist Questions
What is a Prophet?
Cult Assessment Criteria
The Brothers Karamazov
Critique of A New Earth
Buddhist Violence
Some Pertinent Parables
Euhemerism & Catastrophe
Ancient Scholastics
Thoughts on Meditation
Kahlil Gibran on Law
The Great Pyramid
Brother? James Ossuary
Model for Visions & Dreams
Modern Echoes-Catastrophe
The Bergamo Experience
In Search of Moses
Personal Experience
Why I'm not Christian
Importance of Catastrophism
Ancient Explosion Reports
How the World Will End
Unity Church Letter
Reactionary Feminism
Some Conclusions
Woodhenge
Pensée Journal Issues
Video-lecture links

Freud thought that he had identified our triple misfortune, "the superior power of nature, the feebleness of our bodies, and the inadequacy of the regulations which adjust the mutual relationships of human beings in the family, the state and society." - Sigmund Freud, Civilization and its Discontents Vol. 12 of Pelican Freud Library, page 274

Ancient versus Modern Mindset
07/18/2018

We should understand that the culture of myth building that is almost universally practiced by all people certainly enhanced the history that we often take as fact when it is actually not as portrayed. Even in America we see this in the legends of George Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln, etc. These legends pale in comparison to those of Daniel Boone, Davey Crocket, Buffalo Bill, Wyatt Earp, Anne Oakley and more recently Audi Murphy and many others. This being true does not negate that these were real people who lived in a fairly well known chronology and actually did accomplish to some degree, at least partially, those things that were attributed to them.

Herein is raised an important premise that seems clear enough. The examples above are all modern figures which have been chronicled within the modern mindset. The modern mindset in western culture is one where we—rightfully or wrongly (in my opinion)—think that we HAVE established a sensible paradigm of reality, whether that is the Judeo-Christian one, the more modern one of uniformism and evolutionism, or one of several others. Other cultures and especially sub-cultures generally settle on a commonly held paradigm as well. Either way, we have come to the position of TRYING to elucidate the facts generally in a chronological way. Of course, we don’t always do a good job of it and embellishment and distortion confuse the final product.

On the other hand, the post Saturnian breakup ancients were COMPLETELY unsettled in their understanding of reality, and were—although intelligent and talented—PSYCHOLOGICALLY UNHINGED, They had to deal with the DEVASTATING end of the Golden Age with the loss of its significantly benevolent or benign environment compared to ours today. We have developed strategies, tactics, and technologies over the ensuing few thousands of years to deal with harsh seasonal differences and climate changes, established food production techniques, etc. The ancients essentially had to go through a stone age and work their way up to a level of comfort and safety in their existence. Being semi-insane people, they universally anthropomorphized the planets into quasi-human gods and demigods. You and I know how ridiculous that is, and so we should start our understanding of the ancients there, with that fact.

The Hebrew people, such as they were—some think that they were not prominent at all but just a loosely held culture of nomadic shepherds—are no exception. They DID develop into an exceptional culture eventually, but that does NOT mean that they didn’t fabricate their early history and chronology. As far as theology goes, they DID develop a somewhat beautiful understanding of God with their romantic model—as expressed in the Song of Solomon, Hosea, the Book of Esther and some other beautiful Old Testament  allegories—but they were obsessed with their sacrificial system and made absolutely NO progress in understanding the creator to be a human being.

Not that "enlightened" Western culture has achieved full-blown saneness, but we CANNOT legitimately project back upon the ancients the same general level of sanity, mindset, and thinking that we have today. And that, in this context, means that we cannot compare our level of myth creation and legend making to what they did back then. I wonder if very many educated people that you and I would be associated or classed with understand that there are cultures existing today—in the orient, not to mention those more primitive ones in the large southern continents—where logic is a foreign concept because truth and wisdom always come from what the elders say, or the priest, or comes from what is sometimes called "dream time". Maybe the MAJORITY of people in the world today think of truth in one of these ways!

Hebrews and Christians have worked long and hard to “clean up” the accounts in the Old Testament and to make them palatable to generations going back prior to the Reformation. Of course, these canons of Old and New Testaments aren’t even translated properly in some important cases, and people would be staggered if they were. People that take them seriously today generally have to keep quiet about it in public—so to speak—, and there is significant lessening of focus on them in the Christian denominations, even in the fundamentalist ones. The percentage of Jews that take theirs literally are in a dwindling minority.

Bottom line? The pre-flood mythologies/histories/chronologies are largely fabrications done by post flood cultures, and the process of fabrication became somewhat endemic. Just consider the dinosaurs and where they fit—or don’t—in the mythology of the Jews.

Some of the largest distortions are caused by attributing to one of our "heroes" one or more accomplishments that someone of lesser importance did. This is especially true when the actual person doing the "great" thing was of no other significance. We can see this as to things attributed to Newton and Einstein. Newton became England's icon and Einstein became the American media darling. (See: The Establishment Myth of Albert Einstein) We should not be surprised if it also applies to most all famous historical figures. In this light we should have no problem believing that, except for the early towering figures like Adam and Noah, etc., most of the ancient historical "heroes" were real but with many types of distortion, a lot of which was undoubtedly added by those who copied the stories as they were handed down. With this in mind I would add that we can understand why people give credit as well as blame to the wrong people. It is usually the heroes themselves who want credit and to avoid blame. Truth is very rarely the popular choice as we well know.

However, the above doesn’t rise to the level of fabrication and myth making that it all started with in ancient times.

Some of the things which we do know. There are Jews living today that are obviously descended from ancestors with a rich history embedded in their writings whether those writings are quasi-mythical or not. The same can be said as well for other cultures with their "histories" in the respective writings of the Greeks, Romans, Babylonians, Egyptians, etc. The challenge that we are faced with is the monumental job of trying to sort it all out fairly and make some sort of sense of it. The magnitude of the historical and/or chronological distortions is seriously underestimated, given, among other things, large blocks of time have been added to the true, shorter chronologies.

It seems undeniable that cometary catastrophes certainly occurred, as overwhelming evidence for such exists, and we should be VERY comfortable with this catastrophic aspect. A respected Oxford Don and astrophysicist, Victor Clube made a very convincing case for cometary catastrophes having devastated cities and areas of Europe in the C.E. pre-modern times. He has authored a book with Bill Napier called The Cosmic Winter, and has lectured a couple of times at early Kronia or pre-Thunderbolts/EU conferences.

Significant recent changes to the northern coastline of the Mediterranean Sea inundated and/or otherwise destroyed major cities in pre-Roman, Roman, and post-Roman times, and the evidence is even now being excavated on a wide scale, but some of it lies beneath the sea. This area has now become somewhat the new fashion of focus in archaeology.

Just the one global cometary catastrophe, that ended the Roman Empire, and other prominent or controlling cultures around the world, has been buried to the point of being denied and "forgotten". The evidence is there, but it is being studiously ignored, and a HUGE modern mythology has been unconsciously built up to keep it suppressed.

In contemplating the ancient mindset, imagine living is an unsafe world at the mercy of periodic cometary disasters delivered from above with no good way to predict the scale and location of the devastation. For consideration of a "small" modern cometary disaster that destroyed an area almost half the size of Oregon, see:  Great Chicago Fire I, Great Chicago Fire II and Great Chicago Fire III.

The modern mindset has the advantage of time and experience built up over the millennia to insulate us from the memory of physically and psychologically devastating catastrophes. In contrast to the early ancients, we have the tools of mature languages and of information collection, storage and sharing with our writings and libraries and now electronic media, and we have science and technology built up to further insulate us from the exigencies of life on earth.

All of the above factors and more need to be taken into consideration when contemplating the mindset of ancient people.

Home  Site Sections  Complete Article Map   Contact  Store  Contributions